Tuesday, 19 March 2013

Review: The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (IV-VI), by Edward Gibbon

After a very long time I've finished this mighty work. The prolonged period of reading was partly due to the fact I usually read other (easier) books at the same time and mostly because I got bogged down by the tedious, boring early history of Islam. The first three volumes had a similar issue with Christianity, and although that was briefer the Islamic history did at least develop into some exciting warfare (I was particularly interested to learn of Charles Martel's contribution to history).

Gibbon, recognising that he lacked the time to continue his work in the same detail as before, does miss out most of several centuries of Byzantine history. Whilst this is a shame, there are some interesting diversions, perhaps most notable chapters on Genghis Khan, Tamerlane and the splintering and then fall of the caliphate.

The writing style remains sometimes tricky to read, but it's merely highbrow rather than Shakespearian. I was pleased to see that although Gibbon's dislike of Byzantium generally continues he was full of praise for a certain emperor (I shan't spoil it) who suffered a tragic fate.

Towards the end of the work we are taken back to Rome for various shenanigans involving popes and we hear of the final tribune of the Eternal City.

It ends with a couple of appendices, the latter dealing with a list of the Roman emperors and the former with a few pieces of Gibbon regarding the various updates and publications of his work. I must say that I was pleased to hear him refuse to correct or change his earlier work as it would offend those who bought the earlier version, and it brought a wry smile to my face when I read of his decision to retire.

Given these are the final 3 volumes of a 6 volume work you will either have disliked the first set, in which case you would be an idiot to buy this, or you will have enjoyed it, in which case I recommend buying this (although you may wish to skip the religion section).

Overall it's a masterpiece depicting the transient fragility of human endeavour and the construction of mighty edifices which the erosion of virtues and passage of time crumble into dust.



  1. Hey,

    I know this post is ages old but I was curious what shop you bought this Everyman's Gibbon set from. Here in North America the copies sold don't come with dust jackets for each volume and I'd like to get a set like yours (which does).


    1. Hey, sorry for the late reply (no idea why this tripped the filter).

      I got them from Amazon (in the UK) rather than buying in-person. The thumbnail wasn't that accurate, from memory, because it was just the side of the box (which made it look like the cover). I'd be mildly surprised if there's a new version out already, so it's possible that it's an older version in stock (I have vague memories of seeing a 7 volume edition which has all the footnotes in the 7th volume).

      Apologies again for the tardy response.