Tales of Knights and Nitwits: Episode 8

Previous Episode

Next Episode

Full list of episodes

As I mentioned before, episode 9 is due in a fortnight. And if you enjoy this style of comedy, do give The Adventures of Sir Edric, by me, a look. And a buy. 



















Thaddeus

Review: Angel’s Knight, by AJ Grimmelhaus

Angel’s Knight is the third book in the Angelwar Trilogy. Naturally, there will be some spoilers for the preceding books (reviews here for book 1 and here for book 2).

The story follows immediately on from the events of the preceding book, with Tol and Stetch in hot pursuit of the captive Katarina. Elsewhere, a traitor from within the Seven is picking off its knights, and Tol is uncertain just who he can trust.

The writing style is, as you would expect, similar to the other books. Fast-paced, some nice lines to add a sense of realism/humanity, although there were a small number of errors which I hadn’t seen in the earlier books (nothing huge).

I have mixed views about the plot twists. One felt less weighty than it should have because those involved had had relatively little time, particularly in the last book. Another was out of the blue but I felt it worked for that reason (and the nature of the surprise fit well).

I did like the ending, which I shan’t spoil. The ending itself capped both the book and the trilogy nicely.

Thaddeus

Review: Discourses on Livy, by Niccolo Machiavelli

Think Machiavelli and immediately the mind jumps to The Prince. And why not? It’s a damned good book, despite the outrage generated when he had the temerity to be honest about how political reality worked.

However, he also wrote a number of other books, including Discourses on Livy. It’s larger than The Prince’s slender proportions, similar in terms of including advice on governance but differing in the general preference for a republic over a principality.

The Prince was written [in a rush] for a specific individual, Lorenzo de Medici, at a specific time, when it seemed the Medici family might be able to form a solid Italian state and rescue it from what Machiavelli saw as perpetual infighting, leading to weakness and making Italy ripe for foreign invasion.

Discourses on Livy took longer to write, and was not aimed at a specific individual who might give Machiavelli a job and spare him from drudgery. It’s also, as the same suggests, more focused on commentaries about Livy’s (surviving) writing and comparing ancient Rome to modern Italy. There are some other historical and contemporary comparisons, but that’s the heart of it.

You do not not need to have read anything by Livy to get the references, which are explained both by Machiavelli himself and the very helpful notes (as an aside, I still hate endnotes and this edition, by Julia Conaway Bondanella and Peter Bondanella, uses endnotes).

Machiavelli’s commentaries are a mix of domestic governance and military advice, and whilst I don’t agree with everything he says, he does back everything up with his own reasoning and historical/contemporary examples.

The hero-worship of Rome does lead to some questionable conclusions. For example, he praises Hannibal’s skill unstintingly but nevertheless describes the Carthaginian general as treacherous and cruel. The first is a charge made by Romans who thought battle tactics amounted to cheating (specifically cited was his provoking Flaminius into chasing him to Lake Trasimene, which didn’t end terribly well for the Romans), and the second is a shade rich given Livy himself praised his ancestors for wiping out so many adult males from a rival. (Hannibal also never committed genocide, unlike Alexander or Julius Caesar).

However, for the most part Discourses on Livy is an interesting blend of history, politics, and human nature. Unlike many at the time, Machiavelli is ready and willing to face up to the fact that people are capable of acting horrendously in their own self-interest, and that those at the top of politics have their actions governed more by expedience than morality (more recently termed ‘reasons of state’).

The main flaw, endnotes aside, is the Animal Farm problem. Like 1984 to Animal Farm, Discourses suffers a bit by way of comparison with the slimmer and similar ‘other book’. I’d probably suggest buying The Prince, and, if you like it, then giving Discourses on Livy a look.

Thaddeus

Tales of Knights and Nitwits: Episode 7

Previous Episode

Next Episode

Full List of Episodes

Apologies for the slight delay with this episode, beyond the expected wait. The art for episodes 8 and 9 is done and I plan on putting them up something like a fortnight apart. Thanks to those who partook in the recent Twitter naming poll. There will likely be another one, again for a minor character, in the nearish future.
















Thaddeus