Showing posts with label retro-review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label retro-review. Show all posts

Sunday, 31 October 2021

Retro-Review: Shadow Hearts Covenant (PS2)

And so my impossible quest to acquire a PS5 continues, but I have to say having a PS2 and some great games to play in the meantime is a very nice diversion. One of my favourite games (arguably the single best) I’ve ever played is the RPG Shadow Hearts: Covenant. But how does it stand more than a decade and a half down the line? I’ve kept this retro-review as spoiler-free as possible, though the premise is revealed.

As a side note: the PS2 remains magnificent. It’s smaller than its successors, quieter, and the load times are actually quicker.

 

Story

The story sticks with the protagonist of the first game, Yuri Hyuga. He’s an interesting lead for an RPG, as he’s half-Russian, half-Japanese, and the game’s set in the real world (during World War One). Yuri’s a bit of a smartarse, but a likeable fellow, and he’s mourning the love of his life. Germany’s rolling through the Ardennes Forest, and Yuri’s protecting the church where his paramour is buried. Until he suffers a curse and is defeated.

The premise, then, is to cure Yuri if possible, and to stop the group of politico-religious lunatics who attacked him in the first place (the German army brought one of them in to try and take the church). Aided by an assortment of allies including a former German soldier, a very cool wolf, and a vigilante superhero vampire wrestler, Yuri sets about knocking seven bells out of the secret society. But it turns out they have ambitions way beyond him…

It does help a bit to have played the first game, but it’s not essential. Characters that return stand perfectly well on their own and context should not be a problem. The plot moves along rapidly, there’s little flimflam, and my playthrough (not going for many side distractions) took me around 30 hours over the two discs. Yuri’s the focus but most other characters get fleshed out at least a bit. Lucia was, and remains, both my least favourite in gameplay and story terms.

I’d remembered well a certain clash of powers near the end of disc 1 (being deliberately vague) and it was just as fantastic as I remember. The second disc I was fuzzier on, but also has some great moments, both in terms of fun and seriousness. The pillow question still makes me laugh.

There are two endings, good and bad, and more by fluke than memory I managed to get the good one. Take seriously the questions Yuri gets asked about his happiness, if you want to try and get the happy ending. Also, I’d forgotten a post-credits plot revelation so stick around and see what happens.

 

Gameplay

This is a huge strength of Shadow Hearts: Covenant because it makes excellent use of its unique ring mechanic. Instead of just pressing attack and an attack happening, the ring is summoned. Players must then try to hit areas (ranging from 1 upwards, with 4 or 5 eminently possible) to attack the enemy, with strike attacks causing more damage. Miss one and the attack ends (unless you’re using a practice ring). Other ring variations include one with bigger hit areas and no strikes and, I think, small hit areas but bigger strikes. Both areas can be affected by boosts you find throughout the game.

In addition, the ring soul is a cool NPC who bestows an extra attack on you (you determine who gets it) and has some nice dialogue. Explore dungeons properly to increase your chances of finding him, and enjoy the fourth wall-breaking speech you get when you’ve seen him often enough.

The ring is also used for discounts and markups when buying and selling goods, for healing items and spells, and for the lottery. This requires tickets, which you can find here and there, and has some nifty prizes including accessories and crests.

Crests are demonic powers that everyone who isn’t a shapeshifter (like Yuri) can equip. These gift the wearer magical spells. But there’s more to it than that thanks to some smart design decisions by the developer. Slap two Cure crests on one character and that character can cast Cure for half the normal cost. And complete an area of Solomon’s Key (a book of demonic lore where you can place the crests you own) and you can unlock new abilities, so the old crests you got 10 hours ago can still be of value.

The ring also means there are new status abnormalities such as the line speeding up, areas getting smaller, or even the dreaded fake ring which presents a load of false areas to hit. Standard bad statuses (petrification, poison, paralysis etc) also exist and poison’s particularly well done as it can get worse, with deadly poison causing massive damage.

There’s also a sanity depletion system, characters losing one point per turn. Get down to zero and you lose control of that character who just starts going berserk and attacking stuff. This happened to me a grand total of once during the game. Not the most important feature, but it’s there.

Oh, and the ring mechanic also makes it worthwhile to try your best even in easy fights because putting in good performances (such as a perfect ring battle, taking zero damage, or reducing the enemy to no or few turns) can yield rewards including extra cash, experience, and healing items.

 

Graphics

This was the most jarring difference for me, switching from the PS3’s Dragon Age: Origins to the PS2’s Shadow Hearts: Covenant. And your TV better able to take a SCART or you won’t be able to see the regular resolution. I got used to it fairly quickly but at first it really was a step back in time, and not in a good way.

Menus etc are all fine, and the FMV often looks surprisingly good (crying’s interesting. The scene where Yuri cries blood is great, the ones where he cries tears with a sad rather than angry face looks a bit… less so). Textures are often flat or basic and Yuri’s getup (dark grey) can occasionally blend in disconcertingly well with the background. The character design is good, especially Karin, Joachim, and Blanca, and the varying number of attacks is handled well too.

 

Sound

The music’s pretty good in this game and there are moments (again, crying blood scene) where the sound really adds to an already dramatic moment in the story. I also really liked the Saturday morning adventure style theme of Joachim. Voice acting varies a little, even with the same actors, which makes me wonder if sometimes they were lacking context. Kato’s voice is well done, and while we don’t hear Blanca talk too often (he is a wolf, but does speak with other wolves) his boundless confidence and occasional contempt for those who dare challenge him is rather endearing.

 

Bugs and Other Problems

I have very few gripes. No crashes, freezes, hangs, or suchlike, and while save points are required these are very common in dungeons and saving can also occur on the world map.

One problem that did irk me somewhat is that companions not in the party get only half experience. Throughout the game, until disc 2, you don’t need to worry about that at all, or buying them equipment. But then there are two parts (one early in disc 2, one optional and right near the end) that requires the whole party to have good crests and equipment. Because this wasn’t necessary until then you may find (as I did, having forgotten this part) your non-regular characters are incredibly weak, and the lack of warning means you can’t buy some fresh gear. I did get through the story part of this ok but decided to give up on the optional bit (a shame, as the Man Festival is a… unique videogame experience) because Gepetto and Lucia were just rubbish.

 

Replayability

This is an interesting one. There are optional things you can do, if you go looking for them. Completing steps in the pedometer challenge is one such example, likewise completing the Man Festival, finding wolves for Blanca to fight (I didn’t stress these but, if you want to, try going back to areas you’ve cleared out to find more, such as the wine cellar), and fighting the ‘ghosts’ that Solomon’s servant offers you.

The story is a good one and combines the personal strife Yuri faces with potentially cataclysmic events that threaten to reshape, or destroy, the whole world. A bit like The Last of Us, the strong but linear story means it’s a game I like a lot but not one I’ll be replaying in the near future.

 

Conclusion

Shadow Hearts: Covenant looks dated, but in many ways it still knocks the socks off modern counterparts. The ring mechanic really keeps combat engaging and is used smartly throughout, the cast is likeable, the story is both intriguing and moves along rapidly without padding, and the final boss is suitably challenging (I’d cruised through the penultimate fight only to spend an hour or so desperately surviving before getting the upper hand with the last fight). It’s a damned shame Shadow Hearts: Covenant didn’t get a sequel that it deserved, as it’s a humorous, innovative, and very enjoyable game. If you haven’t played it for a while or you’ve got a PS2 kicking about and have a chance to buy a copy, give it a shot. You’re in for a treat.

 

Thaddeus

Sunday, 26 September 2021

(Retro?) Review: Dragon Age: Origins (PS3)

I really liked Dragon Age: Origins when I played it over a decade ago. It was one of my favourite games of all times, but how would it hold up nowadays? For the sake of reference, my PS3 is the original fat version.

Character Creation

Character creation is a whole different beast to other games because, in addition to selecting your sex, race (dwarf, elf, or human), and class (rogue, mage, warrior) players pick an origin. These determine the first two hours or so of your game before converging into the common thread of the plot. Elves have three potential starts (city elf, which is very dark, Dalish, and mage), dwarves have two (both cool, noble and common) and humans have two (noble, also very dark, and mage). Dwarves cannot play as mages for lore reasons.

You make your own face, which mostly works ok except that beards give your characters totally hollow cheeks that look weird. There’s also a decent range of haircuts which were copied in the sequel and replaced with mostly rubbish in Inquisition.

On this occasion I played as a female dwarf warrior with the commoner origin, but during the years I have played every single origin and all of them are good. It’s a great way of making each start distinctive and you will encounter again those you meet at this stage. It’s also excellent at immersing you in your own corner of the world and making you understand things from a certain perspective.

Story and Sound

The story is the single strongest point of Dragon Age: Origins, and the writing team hit it for six. The basic plot is very simple. There’s a blight. Think fantasy zombies called darkspawn plus an undead dragon (there’s more interesting lore to it than that, but that’s the shorthand). Ferelden (a sort of fantasy Britain) is at risk of annihilation. You join the Grey Wardens, the only chaps and ladies who can stop it, and that’s your job.

Players have to rally different factions obligated by ancient treaties to help. But with each group paths can diverge according to how the player acts. You can choose to be super nice (as I did on this occasion) or be brutal (lots of murder-knife action for those who want it). Often these are moral questions or dilemmas with no clear cut answer, but two legitimate yet opposing choices. And because the player has a few of these factions to get on-side, there’s a constant feeling of progress towards the greater goal.

The writing of dialogue, from cutscenes to party banter, is excellent, and the voice acting is great (a particular favourite of mine is Simon Templeman as Loghain). There’s a deep sense of authenticity to the world (if one can say that about a fictional place). The dwarves aren’t just short humans, they have their own civilisation and culture. Similarly with the elves. Companion dialogue is especially good, with differing people getting along well, or not (I went with the classic Alistair-Morrigan party, plus Leliana). Unlike other games, there’s not really a weak link (one might say the dog, who cannot talk) and you can go all the way from sleeping with a companion to annoying them so much they leave or try to kill you.

The music is also good, particularly the main Grey Warden theme.

Gameplay

Combat still works very well, with differing classes bringing different but complementary skills to the table. There are some minor niggles here as frames can drop or the game stutter a little. There’s a good but not enormous range of enemy types, with differing types and level of darkspawn, alongside the mindless undead, revenants, abominations, and good old-fashioned bandits. A nice touch is the mini-slowdown and animation you may get when you kill an ogre.

There’s also a party camp where you can recover from injuries and enjoy some chats with party members (also possible for the three you choose to take into the field), and a merchant.

Graphics

Graphically, things still look pretty good. Character models for companions and the like are decent but do look a shade dated now. Less significant characters are prone to hollow cheeks. I have this turned off, but if you have a sanguine sense of humour, leave the blood spatter on. Having your characters discuss things while covered in blood is, er, interesting. Menus etc are completely fine graphically, lighting effects could be better, fire has a notably low frame rate flicker, but things are basically fine given its age.

Bugs and Other Issues

When it comes to problems I’ve already mentioned the potential in combat for things to stutter a little (it is only a little, it’s an annoyance but not a major one). I did experience three crashes during my playthrough of around 33 hours or so (NB I did not do everything that was possible by a long way). All occurred when entering the menu during combat, and in the latter half of my playthrough. Not ideal. Load times can be on the long side, and you’ll encounter shorter loading when just entering a house in a village, or suchlike.

Replayability

Replayability is excellent. Not only are there the usual differing classes and races to pick, but the unique origins add a lot to the depth of a playthrough. Plus there is a very broad range of outcomes and serious decisions with major consequences. You can be delightfully nice, or a demon-shagging, child-murdering, elf-slaughtering psychopath. Your character might end up dead, or on the throne of Ferelden.

Conclusion

Origins really does stand up as a great game. A few technical points weigh against it (dated graphics, the odd crash) but the core of the game is a match for anything that’s been released since and it remains the best entry in the series by a long way.

 

Thaddeus

Wednesday, 15 May 2013

Retro-review: Worms Armageddon (Playstation)



I was looking through an old CD storage tower and came across a few Playstation games. Vagrant Story, Civilization II, Metal Gear Solid and Worms Armageddon were the stand out ones.

Whilst I enjoyed games like Worms and Lemmings I was never a proper fan, but I remembered liking Armageddon and thought I’d give it a crack. I put together team Bane (Horst, Rufus, Lucia and Urquhart) and dove in.

It was the most fun I’ve had for ages.

Yes, the graphics are old, but it really doesn’t matter, and no, I don’t care that the world is 2-dimensional. This game is all about the gameplay, and that is bloody excellent. It’s as accessible as Lego, but there’s still an element of challenge, particularly when you get to the higher ranks in Deathmatch (at the moment Bane are Highly Distinguished). Firing off a shot that perfectly uses the wind, bagging multiple kills at once (I love the Holy Hand Grenade) and even cocking up massively are all hilariously fun.

There’s a really good range of standard weapons, with one special extra per team and others floating down from the sky. Some get more use than others, of course, and some have unlimited ammunition (bazookas and grenades, for example), but in the last week or two I’ve probably used a good 80-90% of those that are available.

There’s a plethora of accents available for the Worms (I remembered Angry Scots was especially good and switched straight to that), which is a nice touch.

There’s actually a Worms Collection out for the PS3 (and Xbox360) for under £15 which includes Worms Armageddon, Worms and Worms: Ultimate Mayhem. If you’ve never played a Worms game I’d strongly recommend buying it and you’ll soon be cackling with delight.

Thaddeus


 

Saturday, 6 August 2011

Retro-review: Shadow Hearts & Shadow Hearts: Covenant

Shadow Hearts and Shadow Hearts Covenant are both fairly recent games from 2001 and 2004 respectively. They’re innovative RPGs, the first of which was initially planned for the original Playstation but ended up coming out on the PS2 (as did Covenant).

Shadow Hearts is set in the real world, in the early 20th century. The protagonist, Yuri Hyuga, is half-Russian, half-Japanese and is not a typical hero, as the excellent starting cutscene makes plain. Not for Yuri the over-sized sword and kind-hearted nature of a standard RPG protagonist. He’s slightly messed up, a bit cheeky and obnoxious and has the ability to fuse with demons, becoming a range of powerful monsters. He also hears voices. (Well, one voice. And if he disobeys her he gets stabbing pain in his skull).

The intro seems him on a train, rescuing a very sweet Christian girl (with a rather short skirt) from an English gentleman in a top hat who has murdered half the passengers. A cuddly, cutesy RPG this is not.

Compelled by the voice in his head and Alice’s short skirt, Yuri travels with Alice to find out why the gentleman (Roger Bacon) wanted to capture her. They begin in the Far East, where they meet some new party members including the entertaining Zhuzhen, the spy Margarete, an amusing vampire named Keith and an annoying kid called Halley.

The game takes place first in the Far East and then Europe, and sees not only the mystery of Roger Bacon unravelled but the deepening relationship between Yuri and Alice. The dark undertones, excellent writing and three-dimensional characters really do make it stand out.

In particular, the sound is great. There’s no voice-acting outside of cutscenes, but the music is absolutely top notch. The graphics, however, are below par and it’s not hard to see it was originally meant for the Playstation rather than PS2.

Gameplay is excellent. Each of the characters is unique, with Alice wielding holy magic, Zhuzhen more offensive spells, and so forth. An especially innovative and excellent feature is the Judgement Ring. Basically, a character has to hit sections within a circle as a marker moves around it. It sounds simple (and it is) but it also adds a great element of timing and fresh opportunities for status effects. If the player is tired or a bit rubbish at timing it can be turned off, but the opportunity for critical hits (achieved by hitting the last few degrees of a coloured section) is lost.

There are two endings to the game, and a New Game Plus option (the same applies to the following game).

Shadow Hearts: Covenant is a direct sequel, and also on the PS2. Yuri returns but none of the other main characters from the original game are playable.

World War One is well underway, and a certain village in France is protected by a ferocious demon, which is, of course, Yuri. However, a German officer and a man from the Vatican manage to curse him and he and his companions (a puppeteer and Blanca the wolf) are forced to flee. The German officer switches side and joins them. There are a further four characters that join the party, some of which are more, er, interesting than others (the gay vampire superhero being far more original than the rather tedious Lucia, for example).

The first part of the story is about Yuri overcoming his curse and wreaking vengeance upon those who caused it (which is handy, as the same people want to rule the world). Amusingly for a game that starts off with the standard “Any resemblance to events or people living or dead is purely coincidental” message it features Rasputin, Tsar Nicholas II and a few other historical characters.

Later the story shifts from Europe to the Far East, where the party must prevent the destruction of the present timeline and the rewriting of history.

The graphics are a clear step up from its predecessor, the music remains very good and there’s more voice-acting. Something which is a bit niche but I loved was the varying language options, and I used this game to practice my German. The game also has a lot more quirky/surreal/silly humour than the first, and although it has darker moments the tone is generally lighter than its predecessor.

The Judgement Ring is improved upon, with the ability to add new areas for more hits in a standard attack or widen areas. Each character has a unique set of abilities and means of improving them. I especially liked Blanca’s, which involve fighting and defeating other wolves to gain new abilities.

I didn’t include Shadow Hearts: The New World in this retro-review as, although it’s part of the series, it isn’t really a direct follow-on, Yuri isn’t the protagonist and it isn’t as good.

Shadow Hearts and Shadow Hearts: Covenant have sharp writing, fantastic music, an innovative and brilliant combat system and are two of the best modern RPGs there are. It’s a damned shame the series ended after The New World.

Thaddeus

Monday, 9 May 2011

Retro-review: Phantasy Star IV

Phantasy Star IV is about as old school as an RPG can be. It was released over a decade ago for the Sega Megadrive (aka Genesis), and has since been included in a number of Sega collections for the PS2 and PS3.

The game has a number of features which were well ahead of its time, an interesting and pretty large cast of characters and a top notch plot.

For a start, it has two protagonists, Chaz Ashley and Alys Brangwin. They’re both Hunters (mercenaries), with Chaz the apprentice of Alys, who is not so much a mother figure as a feisty aunt figure. They’ve been sent to investigate an outbreak of monsters at a university, but I won’t go further than that with the details of the plot.

The story is connected to the previous instalments of the Phantasy Star series, but you don’t need to have played or read about their plots to thoroughly enjoy IV. There’s no voice-acting, of course, and characters are represented by nicely drawn pictures or 2-D figures. The script is generally excellent and the characters are (script-wise, anyway) very three-dimensional. They flirt, they bicker, they get jealous and pissed off: they’re a decade earlier but a mile better than the likes of Penelo and Vaan from FFXII.

The battle system is pretty damned fantastic. For a start, you get up to 5 party members at a time. Each one has a predefined set of skills and techniques. Techniques are basically magic, and require points to be used. Skills can be used a limited number of times but once they’re exhausted they can’t be used again. Probably the best part of battle is the ability for co-operative attacks, usually with 2-3 members working together to inflict substantial damage. If there’s one gripe with the battle system it’s that techniques and skills are not explained, so if you get a new one you have to use it to see what it does. However, the prefix system (Nares is an improved version of Gires which is an improved version of Res) does help this a bit.

Naturally, the graphics are dated. Unlike Vagrant Story, where things had moved on to three-dimensional dungeons, everything is firmly 2-D. For me, it’s filled with old school charm, though if graphics are your thing it may be a weak point.

There are side quests. As a Hunter, you do get to perform optional Hunts, which are contracts that do not necessarily involving actually hunting something down. In addition, there are areas that you do not need to visit and might only find by exploration. However, the game doesn’t take prisoners and if your levels are too low you’ll end up dying pretty sharpish. The optional areas often have rather tasty equipment for your characters.

Ultimately, this game is one of the best games I’ve every played. It’s up there with Vagrant Story and Shadow Hearts. If you haven’t played it, and aren’t put off by the 2-D graphics, I’d strongly advise you consider buying one of Sega’s collections.

Thaddeus

Saturday, 2 April 2011

Retro-review: Vagrant Story

Vagrant Story was amongst the last and the best of titles to be released for the original Playstation. It’s presently available through PSN, I think, and well worth a look if you never had the pleasure of playing it back in the olden days (2000).

It’s an action RPG featuring Ashley Riot as the protagonist. The player guides Ashley through the abandoned, haunted city of Lea Monde, hunting a prophet thought to be responsible for the death of a nobleman. The prophet, Sydney, captures Ashley’s companion Callo early on, and is also hunted by the Crimson Blades, led by Romeo Guildenstern. The player will also uncover some of Ashley’s history as well as learning more about the main plot.

The music is an excellent feature (one of several) of the game. Numerous tracks are top notch and most are at least enjoyably above average. There is no voice acting. Instead, the characters speak through ye olde speech bubbles. This works well, and is helped by the fantastic translation (by Alexander Smith) which transforms the script into a more archaic form of English. It’s perfectly understandable and has a dash of Shakespearian eloquence which helps immerse the player in the world of Lea Monde. More than that, the game also features a little sprinkling of French, German and Latin which works nicely.

Combat is almost flawless. Excepting the very first few fights, Ashley can execute combo attacks if the player is good enough at timing. But, the more combos the enemy is struck with the higher the Risk gauge rises. Higher Risk lowers the chances of hitting the enemy and increases the damage Ashley takes, introducing an element of strategy to combat.

In addition to this, weapons are highly varied according to material, range and damage type. Materially there are half a dozen different options, from wood to silver. The player has access to a number of workshops in the game, and in these weapons can be combined to create new means of killing enemies. Range can be anything from very, very short to pretty huge (crossbows were always good for killing bats). Players have access to staves, swords, axes, maces, spears and crossbows. Damage type is another intriguing variable which hasn’t been replicated much in subsequent games, I think. Weapons can cause piercing, slashing/slicing and crushing damage. Some enemies are vulnerable to one particular type or resistant to another.

There’s a wide range of enemy archetypes. Many are stereotypical (zombies, bats) but even some of those are excellent (the massive dragons were always fun to kill). There are some slightly creepier and more original foes, such as child-like ghosts or a gigantic iron crab.

Ashley can also learn magic. By acquiring grimoires and using them once he is taught how to perform a certain spell. Elemental resistance/attacks can be very useful in certain fights.

Graphically, the game is clearly dated, but this does not detract from it materially. The only area it slightly annoyed me was in the Snowfly Forest, where the screen is somewhat cluttered and seeing enemies can be tricky. Generally, Lea Monde is enormous, well-designed and fun to play through.

One feature I loved at the time was the award of titles (the ancestor of trophies) for certain deeds. Killing a massive enemy, slaying a certain number of foes with a given weapon or suchlike would yield a title. Vagrant Story also includes a New Game Plus feature, as after the game ends Ashley acquires a key needed to unlock certain doors that cannot be opened in an initial playthrough.

For those wanting a look at it in action, I recommend the excellent review by MetalJesusRocks on Youtube:

So, what score would I give it? 9.5/10. It’s not quite perfect, it’s merely trouser-explodingly fantastic.

Thaddeus