Showing posts with label Norse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Norse. Show all posts

Saturday, 4 March 2023

Review: Tales of Norse Mythology, by Helen A Guerber


Just finished reading this fantastic book, part of the Barnes & Noble Collectible Editions, and it was exactly what I was after.

On the book itself: it’s a lovely leather-bound hardback with gold edging, a ribbon bookmark, and great illustrations within (mostly paintings but some statue photographs).

The text itself dates back around a century, and I think this is for the better. I’ve read a more recent book on Norse mythology that had some very ‘current day’ interpretation (Ivar the Boneless as literally boneless and with cartilage instead as the Vikings moved away from needing a front rank fighter as leader, disregarding and not even mentioning the more likely alternative that his nickname is based on a mistranslation).

Initially, the book covers the origin of the world according to Norse mythology, which also explains the enmity between gods and giants.

Following this, things take a god-by-god approach, with an interesting order. I would’ve assumed, wrongly, that Odin, Thor, and Loki would be the starting chaps, but instead it’s Odin, Frigga (his wife), and Thor, with Loki well towards the end. Each section covers the god’s divine domain, in both the sense of a physical palace or multiple halls and the aspect of reality for which they were responsible. Minor characters of mythology associated with a god, such as Odin’s wolves Geri and Freki, are mentioned in the relevant god’s chapters, as are major stories (origin and shenanigans).

After the gods we come to general chapters covering giants, dark elves/dwarves, and elves. There are also two chapter’s dedicated to sagas (the Volsungs and the Saga of Frithiof) but there’s no mention of definitively real world characters such as Ubba, Ivar the Boneless etc.

Then we come to the penultimate chapter on Ragnarok, and end with an interesting comparison between Norse and Greek mythology which notes the very large number of similarities.

The book’s very easy to read and it’s often noted when there are multiple names (either minor or major variants) for a god or place. Quotations from other texts are used often as well, to good effect, and the artwork is all good stuff. Much detail is present when it comes to gods, with far more than just the main ladies and gentlemen covered and a lot of information on the most significant ones.

I like this book so much that about halfway through reading it I ordered Classical Mythology by the same author. If I were designing what a great mythology book should be, this is it.


As the cunningly astute of you may have surmised, I heartily recommend this book.



Thaddeus


Thursday, 26 April 2018

Review: The Norse Myths, by Carolyne Larrington


Being into history and fantasy, the Norse myths seemed a nice blending of the two, so I bought this book.

The author adopts more traditional spellings for Viking gods (Loki is identical, but Thor’s name is spelt with the rune ‘thorn’ and two Rs). It’s more in keeping with the history, but like Greek names spelt with Ks (Hektor, Akhilleus etc) it can look a bit odd.

Like most people, I have only a passing familiarity with Norse myths (I could name maybe four gods before reading this book), and was interested to learn more. The book begins and finishes with the start and end of the world, with the intervening chapters covering the gods, their opponents, and human heroes.

Loki is the most intriguing fellow, because gods are usually good or evil with small nuance, but he’s genuinely tricky to pin down (amongst his odder feats was becoming impregnated by a giant’s horse and giving birth to Sleipnir, Odin’s eight-legged horse).

An interesting perspective was offered on Thor’s giant-killing antics, which is generally shown as being a good thing, but when he and Loki encounter a sleeping giant, he decides it’s hammer time and tries to smash the giant’s skull in, which looks murderous (and impolite) rather than heroic.

In addition to the myths themselves, there’s also quite a lot of artwork (both from the time and more recent versions in paintings etc) and some mentions of recent literary works (most famously, Tolkien’s stuff) that were influenced by Norse myths.

I especially enjoyed the author’s inclusion of commentary on the impact of Christianity and the dating of certain myths (which affects both Christian influence in storytelling and in the way the gods might be painted as inferior to Jesus). The suggestion put by several ancient writers that the gods were in fact excellent real people, whose deeds led to exaggerations and mythologising, is a neat way of wrapping together ancient Norse myths and (then) contemporary Christian thinking, without discarding wholesale the value or interest in said myths.

Downsides are minor, but irksome. For a start, CE. Common Era is a daft revisionist nonsense applied by some to the Christian calendar (BC/AD becomes BCE/CE) for reasons that are beyond me. There’s also a reference to a certain story reflecting, in the author’s view, ‘the patriarchy’. I’m not fond of imposing modern political perspectives on interpretations of ancient stories.

The book was enjoyable, and a good introduction (from my limited knowledge of the area) to Norse myths. I’d give it four out of five.

Thaddeus